This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
Not all sandwich toppings are created equal. In fact, some ruin an otherwise good meal. This list is a straightforward look at combinations that simply don’t work.
My opinions come from years of witnessing questionable culinary decisions that affect the overall meal. Each topping on this list has a unique flaw that prevents it from harmonizing with classic flavors. Here are 13 offenders that I believe shouldn’t be part of any sandwich.
1. Processed Meats (Like Salami and Bologna)
WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?
Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!
Processed meats are high in sodium, saturated fats, and preservatives like nitrates, which have been linked to heart disease and cancer. These meats can also raise blood pressure, putting older adults at risk for cardiovascular issues.
Opt for lean, freshly cooked turkey, chicken, or roast beef to reduce sodium and enjoy a healthier protein source.
Related Post: 25 Easy Seafood Dish Recipes That Taste Like a Restaurant Meal
2. Full-Fat Mayonnaise
While creamy and flavorful, full-fat mayonnaise is loaded with unhealthy fats and calories, which can contribute to weight gain and elevated cholesterol levels over time.
Switch to avocado, Greek yogurt, or a light mayo alternative to keep your sandwich creamy without the extra calories.
Related Post: 25 Easy Healthy Breakfast Recipes to Start Your Day Right
3. Cheese Slices (High in Saturated Fat)
Many popular sandwich cheeses, like American and cheddar, are high in saturated fat and sodium, which can negatively impact heart health when consumed regularly.
Choose lower-fat cheese options or sprinkle a small amount of flavorful cheese like feta for a healthier alternative.
Related Post: 25 Best Soup Lunch Ideas for a Cozy Midday Break
4. Pickles and Pickled Vegetables
While they add a tangy crunch, pickles are packed with sodium, which can lead to high blood pressure and fluid retention in older adults.
Opt for fresh cucumber slices or lightly pickled vegetables with reduced sodium for a crunchy, heart-healthy option.
Related Post: 25 Soul Food Birthday Dinner Recipes That Will Make You Feel Like Royalty
5. Canned Tuna in Oil
Tuna packed in oil adds unnecessary fats to your sandwich, which can increase calorie intake without providing additional health benefits.
Choose tuna packed in water instead, and mix it with a little Greek yogurt or mashed avocado for added creaminess and nutrition.
Related Post: 25 Cold Weather Dinner Ideas That Might Make You Hibernate All Season
6. Sugary Jams and Jellies
Adding jam or jelly to sandwiches, especially in peanut butter combinations, introduces a lot of added sugar, which can affect blood sugar levels and increase the risk of diabetes.
Use fresh fruit slices like strawberries or bananas to add natural sweetness without the sugar spike.
Related Post: 25 African American Recipes That Are Straight-Up Delicious
7. Creamy Salad Toppings (Like Chicken or Egg Salad with Mayo)
Chicken or egg salads made with lots of mayo are calorie-dense and high in unhealthy fats. They can contribute to weight gain and heart issues if eaten frequently.
Opt for lighter versions made with Greek yogurt, mustard, or avocado for the same creamy texture with fewer calories and more nutrients.
Related Post: 25 Easy Meal Prep Ideas That’ll Change the Way You Eat
8. Bacon
Bacon is delicious but also loaded with saturated fat, sodium, and preservatives, which can raise cholesterol levels and blood pressure—not ideal for heart health.
Consider using turkey bacon or adding a thin slice of smoked turkey for that savory flavor without the health risks.
Related Post: 25 Meal Prep Healthy Snacks You’ll Actually Crave
9. Pâté or Liverwurst
Rich in flavor but high in cholesterol, sodium, and saturated fat, pâté and liverwurst are not the best choices for older adults concerned about heart health.
Try a bean spread like hummus for a savory, creamy texture with fiber and plant-based protein.
Related Post: 25 Soul Food Recipes Southern Foodies Can’t Stop Raving About
10. Barbecue Sauce
Barbecue sauce might add a smoky-sweet flavor, but it’s often packed with added sugars, sodium, and preservatives, which can spike blood sugar and raise blood pressure.
Opt for mustard, a vinegar-based hot sauce, or homemade BBQ sauce with less sugar and sodium.
Sign up now to receive our exclusive e-cookbook filled with top-rated recipes for FREE!
11. Store-Bought Honey Mustard
Many store-bought honey mustard varieties are high in sugar and sodium, which can negatively affect blood pressure and glucose levels in older adults.
Make your own honey mustard with a small amount of honey, Dijon mustard, and Greek yogurt for a healthier, flavorful spread.
Related Post: 25 Black People Dinner Recipes That Bring All the Flavor, Always
12. High-Sodium Deli Meats
Even lean deli meats like turkey or ham can be packed with sodium, contributing to high blood pressure and increased risk of heart disease.
Choose fresh, unprocessed meats or cook your own at home to control the salt content and enjoy a healthier sandwich.
Related Post: 25 Healthy Chicken Recipes That’ll Keep You Satisfied and Guilt Free
13. Processed Spreads (Like Cheese Spreads and Meat Pastes)
These spreads often contain unhealthy fats, artificial additives, and high levels of sodium, all of which can negatively impact heart health and overall well-being.
Opt for natural nut butters, avocado, or hummus to add creaminess without the health risks.
Related Post: 25 On The Go Dinners Families Can Enjoy When Life Gets Crazy
Final Thoughts
Sandwiches can be a quick and easy meal, but the toppings you choose can make a big difference in your health, especially as you get older.
By swapping out high-sodium, high-fat, and heavily processed ingredients for fresh, whole foods, you can enjoy delicious sandwiches that support heart health, manage blood pressure, and maintain overall wellness.
Making small changes to your sandwich routine can lead to big improvements in your health. Your body will thank you for every wholesome bite!
Sign up now to receive our exclusive e-cookbook filled with top-rated recipes for FREE!
Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.
The 15 Worst Snacks Baby Consumers Are Still Buying
While snacking habits have evolved over the years, some nostalgic favorites from the past still linger on grocery lists. Unfortunately, many of these snacks are loaded with sugar, unhealthy fats, and artificial ingredients that don’t do our health any favors.
Read it here: The 15 Worst Snacks Baby Consumers Are Still Buying
12 Budget-Friendly Recipes That Stretch Your Grocery Dollar
When it comes to saving money without sacrificing flavor, the key is finding recipes that maximize simple, affordable ingredients. Packed with bold flavors and clever cooking techniques, each dish stretches your dollar while satisfying your taste buds.
Read it here: 12 Budget-Friendly Recipes That Stretch Your Grocery Dollar
25 Healthy Yogurt Recipes You’ll Never Get Bored Of
Make yogurt your go-to ingredient. Whether it’s pancakes, tarts, or dips, these healthy yogurt recipes can bring a creamy, tangy twist to your table.
Read it here: 25 Healthy Yogurt Recipes You’ll Never Get Bored Of
25 Soul Food Dinner Ideas That’ll Make Even Grandma Jealous
These easy soul food dinner ideas bring in some of the best comfort foods so that you can enjoy a hearty and delicious soul food dinner with the family.
Read it here: 25 Soul Food Dinner Ideas That’ll Make Even Grandma Jealous