This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.

Looking for the Best Substitute For Butter In Mac And Cheese? We’ve got you covered!

What would happen if you replaced half the butter in your favorite macaroni and cheese recipe with olive oil? Would it taste good?

Mac and Cheese

Macaroni and cheese have long been a comfort food staple. The dish was originally created as a way to stretch out limited ingredients during World War II. Today, it remains a classic American dish, often served at family gatherings or potlucks.

Olive oil contains monounsaturated fats, which are known to lower cholesterol levels. Replacing half the butter with olive oil in your mac and cheese recipe could improve its nutritional profile.
The health benefits of olive oil include:

  • It is rich in antioxidants that help protect against heart disease.
  • Olive oil may reduce the risk of certain types of cancer.
  • Olive oil helps prevent diabetes by lowering blood sugar levels.
  • Olive oil can also be used to make salad dressings, marinades, breading, sauces, dips, soups, and other dishes.

Can You Make Mac And Cheese Without Butter?

Looking for the BEST Substitute For Butter In Mac And Cheese? We got you covered!

Macaroni and cheese is a cheesy dish made with noodles and milk or other dairy products. Butter is added to give the macaroni and cheese a creamy taste. Butterscotch chips are used to add flavor to this dish. Butter makes mac and cheese taste better.

You should always add butter when making mac and cheese. Water won’t work as well as milk, but you can still make a great mac and cheese without using butter or milk.

Sour Cream

BEST Substitute For Butter In Mac And Cheese

Sour cream is an excellent alternative to butter in macaroni and cheese. It adds a nice flavor and texture to the dish without adding too many calories or fats. Use less sour cream if you want a more mild taste.

Don’t overuse it because it has a high fat and caloric content. Macaroni and cheese is a classic American dish. You can use plain yogurt instead of milk to make this recipe. This will give you a creamier texture.

We would suggest using less sour cream because of the high content in the ingredients, as it can make your mac and cheese too tangy, actually.

Sour cream is made by mixing yogurt with water or milk. It is used as a garnish for many dishes. It is high in fat and calories, but low in sodium.

A tablespoon is about 2 grams of fat and 120 milligrams of sodium. Try using four tablespoons of sour cream instead of regular mayonnaise when you make pizza.

Cream Cheese

Cream Cheese

Butter substitutes are typically used if your diet needs less saturated fat. You can use cream cheese instead of butter when you require a richer, creamier macaroni and cheese. Cream cheese needs to be softened before being used in recipes.

Heavy Cream

Heavy Cream

You can definitely use heavy cream instead of regular milk in making macaroni and cheese. Heavy cream doesn’t create a roux, but if you want a thicker mac and cheese than usual, you can add some salted pasta water to cut down on the calories.



Margarine is a great alternative to butter in mac and cheese recipes. It tastes exactly like butter, but it’s much better for you. It doesn’t contain any cholesterol or saturated fats, and it’s dairy-free and vegan.

Furthermore, it’s made from plant oils like olive oils, palm, canola, and soybean! You can actually use its salted or unsalted specific variant in your mac and cheese, so get creative with which you’d like to experiment with!

You also don’t usually have to worry about proportions when using margarine as the more you use, the better in this instance, you want your mac and cheese to taste exactly as cheesy and buttery as it usually does.

Margarine is made from vegetable oils and water. It tastes very similar to butter but contains much fewer calories.

It’s a great replacement for butter when making sauces, soups, and other dishes. Furthermore, it can be used as a thickener too. Margarine is a great substitute for butter.

Olive Oil

Olive Oil

Mac and cheese made with olive oil taste great, but it doesn’t add much to the dish. You can use more than a teaspoon of mayo to make it thicker.

Sour cream is another option to give your mac and cheese a tangier taste. Olive oil is healthier than butter or margarine, but it won’t add any extra flavor.

Plant-Based Butter

Plant-Based Butter

Plant-based butter is similar to regular butter and margarine. They are gluten- and dairy-free and act similarly to regular butter and Margarine. They can be used to make flourless cakes or muffins.

Tahini and Peanut Butter

Tahini and Peanut Butter

Vegan and vegetarian options are great for macaroni and cheese. Tahini and peanut butter can be used as an alternative to butter. Both contain high-fat content, which makes them perfect for mac and cheese.

Why Do You Need Butter For Mac and Cheese?

Butter is typically used when making macaroni and cheese. But, if you don’t have any butter, there are other options. You can substitute margarine, vegetable oil, or even olive oil. These alternatives bring different tastes to the macaroni and cheese recipe.

Mac and cheese aren’t really made with butter. It tastes better when you use full-fat cream instead of low-fat or skimmed milk. You need to cook the noodles until they’re soft, but you should avoid overcooking them.

You can add more cheese to your mac and cheese if you want. Mac and cheese without butter are made by cooking pasta until al dente. Then, you mix together the cooked pasta with milk and flour. Add salt, pepper, and other spices to taste.

Top with Parmesan cheese and bake until golden brown. Mac and cheese without butter are made by cooking pasta al dente, draining the water, adding two cups of milk, stirring together, then adding another cup of milk.

Cheese and spices are added and stirred until melted. Served hot.

Final Thoughts: Substitute For Butter In Mac And Cheese

Mac and Cheese is an American dish made with pasta and cheese sauce. Butter is used as a main ingredient in the recipe. Milk products such as heavy cream, milk, and buttermilk are also used in this dish.

Other ingredients include flour, eggs, salt, and pepper. You can substitute any of these ingredients to create your own version of mac and cheese.

In conclusion, making mac and cheese without butter is an achievable goal to make your favorite comfort food healthier and more delicious.

This smoked mac and cheese recipe is a delicious twist on the classic comfort food that adds a rich and smoky flavor to the creamy and cheesy goodness you know and love.

Your turn! Will you be trying a substitute for butter in mac and cheese?

For more frequently asked questions, visit our index of food-related questions and answers. Here are a few suggestions for you:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *