This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
While pizza still dominates many menus, several Italian classics are quietly taking the lead in popularity across different parts of the country. From pasta staples to rich baked favorites, these dishes are being ordered more frequently than ever.
Diners are craving comfort, richness, and the kind of meals that feel like home cooking. Here are the dishes that are holding their own and often surpassing pizza, in states where Italian food is serious business.
Chicken Parmigiana is the Go to Italian Order in New Jersey
WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?
Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!
Served with melted mozzarella over crisp cutlets and rich tomato sauce, this dish has become a weeknight staple. Many diners say it offers both warmth and satisfaction in every bite. It consistently outsells pizza in family style Italian restaurants statewide.
Fettuccine Alfredo Leads in Virginia’s Upscale Italian Spots
This creamy, butter rich pasta dish is the most requested item in several Northern Virginia trattorias. Locals love it paired with grilled chicken or shrimp. The smooth texture and full flavor keep it ahead of other menu items.
Lasagna Bolognese Dominates in Illinois’ Italian Bakeries
Layered with béchamel, slow cooked meat sauce, and fresh pasta, lasagna continues to draw long lines. In Chicago suburbs, it is frequently pre ordered in trays for weekends. Many bakeries report that it outsells pizza by far.
Eggplant Parm is a Vegetarian Favorite in Massachusetts
In Boston’s North End and surrounding towns, this cheesy eggplant dish holds its own as a meatless classic. Baked until golden and served over pasta, it draws loyal orders. Locals say it delivers comfort without compromise.
Baked Ziti is a Family Classic in Pennsylvania Homes
Packed with tomato sauce, ricotta, and bubbling mozzarella, baked ziti is often chosen over pizza for large gatherings. Italian American families say it is easier to serve and more filling. It remains a top pick at Italian delis and home kitchens alike.
Stuffed Shells Stay Popular in Upstate New York
Jumbo pasta shells filled with creamy ricotta and covered in marinara continue to win over diners. They are especially loved in towns where Italian American roots run deep. They regularly outsell pizza at sit-down spots.
Related Post: 10 Delis Where The Owners Know Everyone By Name
Rigatoni alla Vodka is Rising Fast in Connecticut
Creamy and rich with a touch of tomato, this pink sauce pasta is now a best-seller in trendy bistros across the state. It has become the dish that younger diners order first. Some spots say they can never prep enough.
Related Post: 13 Cafes In The Rockies That Are Worth The Road Trip
Gnocchi alla Sorrentina is the Star in Rhode Island
These soft potato dumplings baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella are winning over Providence area diners. The dish is described as comforting and deeply flavorful. It outsells many pasta options and holds steady against pizza orders.
Related Post: 12 Foods That Shouldn’t Taste Good Together But Somehow Do
Veal Saltimbocca Stands Out in Florida’s Italian Hubs
Topped with prosciutto and sage, this sautéed veal dish is popular in Italian enclaves like Naples and Boca Raton. Diners say it feels more refined than red sauce fare. Restaurants often rank it among their top three entrees.
Related Post: 14 Things You Should Never Store In The Fridge, But Probably Do
Penne Arrabbiata Brings the Heat in Texas
This spicy tomato based pasta is catching on in cities like Austin and Houston, where bold flavors are in demand. It is often ordered with extra chili or sausage. Many kitchens say it sells out before more traditional items.
Related Post: A Letter From Your Fridge After A Rough Week
Osso Buco is the Surprise Favorite in Northern California
Braised veal shank served over risotto is seeing a revival in high-end Italian restaurants. The depth of flavor and slow cooked tenderness have brought it new fans. Some chefs say it is ordered more than pizza at special dinners.
Related Post: 13 Grocery Chains In The US That Are Secretly Luxury Experiences
Sign up now to receive our exclusive e-cookbook filled with top-rated recipes for FREE!
Manicotti Keeps its Hold on Louisiana Italian Menus
With its rolled pasta, rich cheese filling, and generous sauce, manicotti is still loved in places like New Orleans and Baton Rouge. Diners call it nostalgic and festive. It continues to lead in both restaurant orders and home cooked meals.
Related Post: 13 Grocery Chains In The South Where Prices Shock Everyone
Sign up now to receive our exclusive e-cookbook filled with top-rated recipes for FREE!
Across the country, these Italian dishes are proving that pizza is not the only star of the show. Their textures, richness, and tradition speak to diners seeking more than convenience. These meals keep showing up on tables and staying there.
Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.
12 Delis In The South Where Barbecue Meets Sandwich Perfection
There is a special kind of magic that happens when slow-smoked meats meet warm, fresh bread. Somewhere between the scent of hickory and the crunch of a perfectly grilled bun, you find a sandwich that does more than satisfy hunger, it honors tradition and flavor all at once. In the South, barbecue is not just food. It is a living story written in smoke and spice, and some delis are telling it one stacked sandwich at a time.
Read it here: 12 Delis In The South Where Barbecue Meets Sandwich Perfection
How to Save $100+ Every Month at the Grocery Store
From planning your meals to avoiding sneaky upcharges in the snack aisle, here’s a realistic guide to trimming your food budget without adding stress to your week.
Read it here: Things Moms Waste Money On (and Don’t Even Know It)
Is Walmart+ Still Worth It in 2025? The Truth After 3 Years
Is the new Walmart Plus worth the annual fee or is it just another failed version of Amazon Prime? I spent my own money trying this service out for 12 months and counting. I have a lot to say about the benefits and drawbacks in this Walmart+ honest review.
Read it here: Is Walmart+ Worth It? Honest Review 3 Years Later!
You’ll love these related posts:
- 10 Restaurants In Arizona Serving Dishes You’ve Heard Of But Will Never Forget
- 12 Restaurants In New Orleans That Will Change How You Feel About Dining Out
- 11 Fast Food Chains In The Southwest With Cult Followings You Never Knew Existed
- 10 Grocery Chains In America That Are Quietly Disappearing
- 14 Delis In Chicago Locals Say Outsiders Just Don’t Understand