This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
Searching for the best Substitute For Milk In Mac And Cheese? We got you covered!
Mac and cheese has long been a favorite comfort food and is a classic dish that kids love. However, if you’re in a bind without any regular milk in the refrigerator or simply can’t consume milk, you might be curious to know a substitute for milk in mac and cheese.
In this article, I will cover a variety of different substitutes for milk in mac and cheese. So, next time you’re making mac and cheese, you have plenty of inspiration. Let’s get into it.
WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?
Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!
While mac and cheese is delicious, it’s not always suitable to eat for a variety of different reasons, such as dietary requirements, which is why many people like to switch up the traditional ingredients.
Whatever reason you’re looking for a substitute for regular milk in mac and cheese, the good news is that there is a tonne of options out there.
So, whether you’re looking for a non-dairy milk substitute, or just want to switch up the traditional recipe, what are some of the substitutes you should be aware of?
Substitute For Milk In Mac And Cheese
Sour Cream
Sour cream makes a great substitute for milk in mac and cheese. It has a wonderful tangy flavor that brings a complex flavor profile to your mac and cheese.
You will want to opt for 1 tablespoon of sour cream and see how you go from there if you think the recipe requires more.
Cream Cheese
One of the best alternatives to milk is cream cheese. It has a very mild, slightly sweet taste that closely resembles that of milk.
As it’s got a thicker consistency, you can also decide whether you’d like to omit the butter from your recipe when using cream cheese as a substitute to milk in a 1:1 ratio.
There are also a variety of non-dairy substitutes to cream cheese if you’re vegan or struggle with lactose intolerance.
Plain Yogurt
Have you got some plain yogurt in the refrigerator? Then why not chuck into your mac and cheese recipe instead of milk?
Plain yogurt and sour cream are similar both in consistency and taste, as they both have a somewhat sour taste.
Yogurt is packed full of protein and provides your mac and cheese with a rich flavor and smooth texture.
Coconut milk
If you’re looking for a vegan or plant-alternative for milk, then canned coconut milk makes an excellent substitute.
Although coconut milk has a strong nutty flavor, when incorporated into a mac and cheese dish, the flavor isn’t quite as strong.
Despite the fact that you’ll be able to notice a slight difference in taste, it won’t be overpowering and will provide you with a beautifully rich and creamy consistency that isn’t too dissimilar from traditional mac and cheese.
Plus, if you like the additional flavor of coconut, it’s a win-win!
Almond Milk
Another great alternative if you’re vegan or lactose intolerant is almond milk.
There are both sweetened and unsweetened varieties, and which you choose is up to your preference. The sweetened variety is better for mac cheese sauce because it imitates the sweetness of the milk better.
When using this substitute, opt for a 1:2 ratio of almond milk to milk. This comes down to the fact that almond milk has a very nutty taste that could overpower your mac and cheese if you’re not careful.
Whipping Cream
If you’re not worried about the calories, then you can always try whipping cream as a replacement for milk. This will result in a super-indulgent creamy cheese sauce and richer taste that makes the ideal comfort food.
That being said, it’s not the healthiest option, and you will want to omit the butter from your recipe when using cream.
If using this substitute, opt for a 1:1 ratio.
Cashew milk
Another milk alternative is cashew milk. The good thing about cashew milk is that it has a rich, neutral taste and a silky, smooth consistency that blends beautifully with cheddar cheese.
For a creamy flavor, use this substitute in a 1:1 ratio.
How Do You Reheat Mac And Cheese?
Mac and Cheese can be reheated in a variety of different methods. While some people prefer microwaving leftover mac and cheese, others prefer cooking it on the stovetop or reheating it in the oven.
Since your mac and cheese noodles have already been cooked once, it’s just a case of heating the dish through, so you can enjoy it.
Each reheating method will vary when it comes to timings, so make sure that you’re checking timings in accordance with the method that you choose.
For the quickest mac and cheese, the microwave is the easiest option.
Is Mac & Cheese Creamy Without Milk?
While whole milk is great for achieving that smooth, creamy sauce that you’d expect from a good mac and cheese, there are a variety of different ways to make your mac & cheese creamy without milk.
However, mac and cheese made without milk can be creamy, provided that you opt for the right substitute. Other ingredients that will make up for the creamy taste of whole milk include cream cheese, cream, and plain yogurt.
What Types Of Cheese Should I Use?
There are a variety of different cheeses that you can use to make mac and cheese. This is what makes the dish so versatile! Sharp cheddar cheese is always a wonderful option for classic mac and cheese.
That being said, many people opt for cheeses such as parmesan cheese, soft cheese, and even blue cheese if you’re that way inclined.
The main thing to remember when choosing your cheese is that you want to opt for cheeses that not only blend well together in terms of flavor, but that also are easy to melt in the pan.
This will help you to create a beautifully smooth cheese mixture.
In Summary: Substitute For Milk In Mac And Cheese
There are a variety of excellent substitutes for milk in mac and cheese.
Hopefully, after reading this article you are now more familiar with the variety of different substitutes you can use for Mac and cheese.
Once you have more confidence in switching out your milk, you can try incorporating different cheeses into your mac and cheese recipes.
Get creative and enjoy experimenting in the kitchen with a variety of different cheeses that complement each other in flavor for a mac and cheese sauce.
Good luck making your mac and cheese without milk! Your turn! Will you try a substitute for milk in mac and cheese?
For more frequently asked questions, visit our index of food-related questions and answers. Here are a few suggestions for you: