5 Thanksgiving Leftover Mistakes a Registered Dietitian Says to Stop Making, From Waiting Too Long to Freeze to Reheating the Same Plate

This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.

Lindsay Fencl, a registered dietitian at Aurora Health Care, named five Thanksgiving leftover mistakes in a Nov. 20 article on the health enews site. The list runs from leaving food out on the counter to reheating the same meal day after day, and takes in reheating that falls short, keeping leftovers too long and waiting too long to freeze them. Her safety advice lines up with the USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service, though the federal freezer timeline is shorter than hers.

Leftovers Left on the Counter Past Two Hours

The first mistake Fencl lists is leaving food out too long. The article points out that it is easy to linger at the table after dinner while the dishes sit on the kitchen counter, and that leftovers should be packed up before they spoil.

Perishable food should go into the refrigerator within two hours of being served, Fencl said. Large portions should be divided into shallow containers first so they cool quickly and evenly.

The USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service gives the same limit on its “danger zone” page: never leave food out of refrigeration over two hours, or over one hour when the temperature is above 90 degrees. It says bacteria grow most rapidly between 40 and 140 degrees, doubling in number in as little as 20 minutes.

The agency’s leftovers guidance adds that a big pot of soup takes a long time to cool, and that turkey should be cut into smaller pieces before it goes in the fridge, with the breast sliced and the legs and wings left whole.

Warm Does Not Mean 165 Degrees

The second mistake is not reheating leftovers thoroughly. The article notes that a plate feeling warm coming out of the microwave does not mean all of the food has reached a safe temperature.

She said leftovers should reach an internal temperature of 165 degrees Fahrenheit, the same figure the USDA lists for leftovers and casseroles on its safe minimum internal temperature chart. Gravies, soups and sauces should be brought to a rolling boil before they are served again.

Fencl also recommends covering food to hold in moisture and stirring or rotating it halfway through reheating to get rid of cold spots. The USDA’s leftovers guidance makes the same point about microwaves and says to check the temperature in several places with a food thermometer. For the question of how many times a plate can be warmed up, a food safety expert’s view on reheating leftovers more than once explains how the two-hour clock adds up.

The Fridge Window Is Three to Four Days

The third mistake is keeping leftovers too long. By Monday the container of turkey may still look perfectly fine, but the article says looks, smell and even taste are not reliable ways to judge whether leftovers are safe.

Thanksgiving foods should stay in the refrigerator for only three to four days, she said. If they will not be eaten in that time, she suggests sharing them with family or friends or freezing them. “When in doubt, throw it out,” Fencl said, because harmful bacteria are not always visible, detectable by smell or noticeable by taste.

The USDA gives the same range, and a hospital dietitian recently argued for a shorter 72-hour window. The full federal range and how it applies to each dish is laid out in a look at how long Thanksgiving leftovers last in the fridge.

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!

Freezing Early, and What Does Not Freeze Well

The fourth mistake is waiting too long to freeze. Many Thanksgiving staples freeze well and keep good quality for three to six months when stored properly, Fencl said, and the best results come from freezing leftovers within the first few days rather than near the end of their refrigerator life.

Her storage advice is to portion leftovers into individual or family-sized containers and label each one with the contents and the date. Airtight freezer bags or containers help prevent freezer burn and preserve freshness. Turkey, stuffing, gravy, mashed potatoes, sweet potato casserole, soups and homemade turkey broth are all good candidates, she said.

Cream-based dishes, including casseroles and pies, may turn watery or change texture after freezing and reheating.

The USDA’s guidance is more conservative on timing. It says leftovers can be frozen for 3 to 4 months and stay safe indefinitely, though they can lose moisture and flavor if kept longer. In its freezer storage chart for food held at 0 degrees, gravy, casseroles, and soups and stews are listed at 2 to 3 months and cooked poultry at 4 months, and the agency notes that freezer times are for quality only. Frozen leftovers can be reheated without thawing, or thawed in the refrigerator and used within 3 to 4 days, and the agency says perishable food should never be thawed on the counter.

Giving the Same Plate a Second Life

The fifth mistake is eating the same plate over and over. Food safety is not the only reason Thanksgiving leftovers end up in the trash, the article says, because eventually people tire of eating the same foods for the fourth day in a row.

Instead of reheating the same meal, she recommends turning leftovers into something new. Her suggestions:

  • Turkey: cranberry turkey sandwiches or wraps, noodle soup, chili, quesadillas, pot pie or fried rice.
  • Mashed potatoes: potato pancakes, waffles or soup, or a topping for shepherd’s pie.
  • Stuffing: breakfast muffins or waffles, or a casserole topping.
  • Cranberry sauce: mixed into yogurt or oatmeal, blended into a smoothie, or added to sandwiches, pancakes or waffles.
  • Roasted vegetables: soup, salads, grain bowls, omelets or frittatas.

However the holiday favorites get a second life, Fencl said, a few food safety basics keep leftovers as safe as they are delicious.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Famartin – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *