13 Pizzeria Toppings With The Most Customer Complaints

Pizza brings people together, but toppings can just as easily tear opinions apart. Some ingredients spark strong reactions, turning an otherwise perfect slice into a disappointment fast.

From bold flavors to strange textures, these controversial toppings have earned more complaints than compliments. Some are too strong, others too soggy, and many just do not belong.

Anchovies

The salty punch of anchovies is either loved or instantly rejected. Many say it overwhelms every other flavor on the pizza, leaving no room for balance. Others dislike the fishy smell, even if they never ordered it themselves. It divides people more than it connects them.

Pineapple

Sweet on a savory base, pineapple continues to be one of the most argued about toppings. Some find the contrast refreshing, while others call it a mistake. Complaints usually center around the texture when baked and how the juice can soak the crust, making it soggy.

Jalapeños

Spice lovers enjoy jalapeños, but not everyone welcomes the heat. Complaints often focus on the unpredictability of spice levels and how they can overpower delicate ingredients. Some say they order mild pizza for a reason and get upset when it feels more like a challenge.

Artichokes

While artichokes are praised by some for their unique taste, others describe them as tough and bitter. Complaints usually come from those unfamiliar with the texture, which can seem out of place. When not cooked properly, they become stringy, adding more trouble than taste.

Raw Onions

Onions bring flavor, but raw ones come with a sharp bite and lingering aftertaste. Customers often complain about the crunch and smell clashing with warm cheese. When served cold or undercooked, the onions can stand out too much instead of blending with the rest.

Capers

These little briny bursts are often confused with peppercorns and surprise diners in the worst way. Capers bring a sour pop that some find unpleasant. Complaints tend to mention how they hide under cheese, only to be discovered mid bite with no warning at all.

Related Post: 13 Things That Vanished From Red Robin Menu

Whole Olives

Whole olives might seem like a great choice until someone bites into one with a pit. Even without pits, the texture can be rubbery and tough. People also complain about uneven placement, where a few bites are overloaded and others have none at all.

Related Post: 13 High Protein Restaurant Meals That Still Taste Like Comfort Food

Broccoli

Though some pizza lovers appreciate the vegetable boost, broccoli is often described as too dry or too chewy after baking. It can burn quickly in high heat, leaving behind a bitter flavor. Others say it makes the pizza feel more like leftovers than a treat.

Related Post: 15 Burger Toppings That Vanished Overnight Because Of The FDA

Ground Beef

Unlike pepperoni or sausage, ground beef can feel grainy and dry once baked. Customers complain that it lacks seasoning or spreads unevenly. Some say it reminds them more of fast food tacos than pizza night. When overcooked, it adds more grease than taste.

Related Post: 12 Low Calorie High Protein Orders You Can Get Without Annoying The Chef

Canned Mushrooms

Canned mushrooms tend to bring more complaints than fresh ones. People often describe them as slimy or rubbery, with a flavor that lacks depth. They can also make the pizza soggy underneath. Some customers say they would rather have no mushrooms at all than canned.

Related Post: 13 State Favorite Food Brands That Outsiders Are Just Discovering

Spinach

Spinach may seem harmless, but once baked, it can turn slimy or shrink into dark patches. People say it affects the look and moisture of the pizza. Complaints often come from those expecting a crisp texture but instead finding soggy leaves stuck to the cheese.

Related Post: 14 Ways U.S. And Canadian Bodegas Are Completely Different According To Shoppers

Sign up now to receive our exclusive e-cookbook filled with top-rated recipes for FREE!

Truffle Oil

Truffle oil brings an earthy aroma that either impresses or overwhelms. Some call it fancy, while others say it smells like gasoline or mushrooms gone bad. The strong scent alone triggers reactions. Complaints also mention that it masks the tomato and cheese underneath.

Related Post: 12 Fast Food Meals With Protein Levels That Rival Your Gym Smoothie

Eggplants

Eggplants do not always hold up well on pizza. When sliced too thick, they can be chewy and bitter. If too thin, they turn mushy and blend awkwardly. Customers often say the texture is inconsistent and the taste is too earthy for something meant to be comforting.

Related Post: 15 U.S. Bodega Traditions That Confuse First Time Canadian Visitors

Toppings can take a pizza from comfort food to controversy in one bite. While taste is deeply personal, these ingredients show up often in customer complaints for a reason. Whether it is a texture that feels off, a flavor that overpowers, or a surprise no one asked for, each topping on this list has pushed the limits of what belongs on a slice.

Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.

15 Burger Chains That Replaced Banned Ingredients With These Unexpected Swaps

Burgers are comfort food for many of us, but behind the scenes, things keep changing. Ingredient bans have forced burger chains to rethink old recipes and find clever replacements.

Some swaps are so seamless you barely notice. Others have fans talking, wondering why a familiar burger suddenly tastes a little different. Let’s check out what has been secretly switched out.

Read it here: 15 Burger Chains That Replaced Banned Ingredients With These Unexpected Swaps

How to Save $100+ Every Month at the Grocery Store

From planning your meals to avoiding sneaky upcharges in the snack aisle, here’s a realistic guide to trimming your food budget without adding stress to your week.

Read it here: Things Moms Waste Money On (and Don’t Even Know It)

Is Walmart+ Still Worth It in 2025? The Truth After 3 Years

Is the new Walmart Plus worth the annual fee or is it just another failed version of Amazon Prime? I spent my own money trying this service out for 12 months and counting. I have a lot to say about the benefits and drawbacks in this Walmart+ honest review.

Read it here: Is Walmart+ Worth It? Honest Review 3 Years Later!