This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
Grocery shopping in New York is already a juggling act between convenience, quality, and price. But some stores are quietly charging more than you might realize, even for everyday essentials.
Whether it is the markup on produce or the price tag on pantry basics, these spots are known for ringing up more than expected. Here are the stores where you might be spending more than you need to.
Whole Foods Market
WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?
Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!
Whole Foods is known for its organic selection, but many of its prices are noticeably higher than local competitors. While the produce looks fresh and the aisles are curated, basic items like eggs, milk, and bread can cost significantly more than they do at neighborhood markets.
Gristedes
A longtime city staple, Gristedes charges premium prices for convenience. The stores are often located in high traffic areas, but many locals say the products do not justify the price. Expect to pay more for brand names and even generic items than at national chains.
Morton Williams
With locations all across Manhattan, Morton Williams is a quick stop for many New Yorkers. But with that convenience comes a consistent markup. Prepared foods and packaged snacks are especially costly, and many shoppers walk out with fewer items than they planned for the budget.
D’Agostino
Once a go to for Upper East Siders, D’Agostino has struggled to compete with larger chains. While the shelves are stocked, the prices on everyday goods can be surprisingly high. Items like pasta, cereal, and household goods often ring up well above city averages.
Westside Market
Westside Market is loved for its gourmet appeal, but that upscale branding shows up in the bill. Specialty items, imported cheeses, and even fruit come with a higher price tag. It is great for a treat or quick lunch, but not for regular grocery hauls.
Food Emporium
Food Emporium leans into a higher end presentation, but the costs often outweigh the quality. Shoppers report that basics like produce and meat tend to cost more here, and even sale items do not compete with prices at Trader Joe’s or discount stores nearby.
Related Post: 15 Genius Ways to Add More Protein to Meals Without Breaking the Bank
Key Food
While some Key Food locations offer reasonable deals, others are noticeably pricier. It depends on the neighborhood, but in many parts of the city, you can expect to pay more for staples. And the quality does not always match the premium you are paying.
Related Post: The 15 Worst Snacks Consumers Are Still Buying
Fairway Market
Fairway has a strong reputation, but its prices have steadily increased in recent years. While the selection is impressive, from olive bars to artisan bread, it is easy to overspend without realizing it. Bulk items and center aisle products often carry a significant markup.
Related Post: 10 Illinois Restaurants That Have Been Around Longer Than Most People’s Jobs
Zabar’s
Zabar’s is a New York icon, and worth visiting for the experience. But as far as everyday grocery shopping goes, it is expensive. Items like smoked fish, gourmet spreads, and specialty coffee add up quickly. It is more of a splurge than a staple stop.
Related post: 15 Brilliant Recipes That Use Pantry Staples You Already Have
Citarella
Citarella is all about luxury groceries, but that luxury comes at a price. Their seafood and butcher counters are excellent, yet the total at checkout is often eye opening. This is a store where presentation and location are baked into every price tag.
Related post: 12 Packaged Food Ripoffs That Have Quietly Gotten Worse
Amish Market
Amish Market has several locations in Manhattan and is popular for hot meals and prepared foods. But if you are grocery shopping here, expect to pay more. The artisanal appeal drives up costs on pantry items, produce, and snacks that could be found for less elsewhere.
Related Post: 13+ Grocery Hacks That Instantly Slash Your Bill (You’re Overpaying Without Them!)
New York grocery stores offer convenience and character, but they often come at a steep price. These spots may have loyal followings, but they are also where budgets go to disappear. If you are looking to save, it might be time to rethink where you fill your cart.
Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.
10 Arizona Grocery Stores That Locals Say Are Surprisingly Affordable
From budget-friendly produce to international pantry staples, Arizona is home to a wide range of grocery stores that deliver serious value without skimping on quality.
Whether you’re a bargain hunter or just trying to stretch your food budget, these 10 local favorites are known for low prices and high satisfaction.
Read it here: 10 Arizona Grocery Stores That Locals Say Are Surprisingly Affordable
11 Ohio Grocery Stores With Shockingly Good Bakery Sections
When you think of great bakeries you might not picture a grocery store but Ohio locals know better.
Hidden inside everyday markets are bakery sections turning out the softest breads creamiest pies and dreamiest pastries. These grocery store bakeries are local secrets that prove you do not have to visit a café for bakery perfection.
Read it here: 11 Ohio Grocery Stores With Shockingly Good Bakery Sections
Is Walmart+ Still Worth It in 2025? The Truth After 3 Years
Is the new Walmart Plus worth the annual fee or is it just another failed version of Amazon Prime? I spent my own money trying this service out for 12 months and counting. I have a lot to say about the benefits and drawbacks in this Walmart+ honest review.
Read it here: Is Walmart+ Worth It? Honest Review 3 Years Later!
You’ll love these related posts: