This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
A Rutgers University food scientist has put a number on what counts as a shallow container for leftovers. According to an Associated Press Thanksgiving food-safety report published Nov. 21 and carried by NBC Bay Area and KPTV, Donald Schaffner’s research found that food cooled in containers no more than 2 inches deep posed little risk of dangerous germ growth.
Schaffner co-hosts the food-safety podcast “Risky or Not?” and is quoted in the AP piece alongside North Carolina State University food scientist Benjamin Chapman. The 2 inches is his research finding as the AP reported it, not a federal rule, and it is a little tighter than the 3 inches that Rutgers lists in its own leftovers guidance.
The 2-Inch Finding as the AP Reported It
The AP report says leftovers should go into the refrigerator within two hours of coming off the stove. For dense foods, it points to shallow containers so the food cools faster, and it names sliced turkey, sweet potatoes and gravy as examples.
Schaffner’s research, the AP wrote, found that containers no more than 2 inches deep posed little risk of dangerous germ growth. The report did not describe how the research was done, so the figure stands as a reported finding rather than a published standard.
Why Large Masses of Food Cool Slowly
The same report notes that cooling takes longer when food is packed in a large mass. That matters because bacteria grow easily between 40 and 140 degrees Fahrenheit, a range the AP report calls the danger zone. Slower cooling keeps food in that range for longer.
North Dakota State University Extension put numbers on the problem in publication FN1381, reviewed in August 2022. In its test, chili in a five-gallon pickle bucket in a 40-degree cooler had not reached 41 degrees after 20 hours. The same chili in a two-gallon plastic container got there in about 10 hours.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention points to the same habit in restaurants. Its food-cooling page says about 4 in 10 restaurants placed hot food in containers deeper than 3 inches, and that food cooled faster when it was kept in shallow pans.
Where Other Extension Services Draw the Line
The 2-inch figure is not new to extension guidance. Mississippi State University Extension’s HappyHealthy page on cooling and refrigerating food, updated in July 2020, tells readers to limit the depth of food to 2 inches.
North Dakota State splits the question by texture. Chunky or thickened foods should be no more than 2 inches deep because they take longer to cool, its publication says, while liquid foods can be up to 3 inches deep. The publication also says foods cool more quickly in metal pans than in plastic containers.
Schaffner is a co-author of a Rutgers Cooperative Extension fact sheet, FS588, published in December 2019 with Sara Elnakib. That fact sheet advises small, shallow containers “three inches tall or less.” The two numbers do not conflict: 3 inches is the ceiling in the 2019 fact sheet, and 2 inches is the depth the AP says his research found carried little risk.
The Two-Hour Clock and What Happens After
Shallow containers do not extend the time food can sit out. In the AP report, Schaffner’s advice is still to refrigerate leftovers within two hours of leaving the stove. The Rutgers fact sheet sets the same two-hour limit, or one hour in hot weather, and Mississippi State says food does not need to be completely cool before it goes into the refrigerator.
The sources differ on covering. Rutgers says to cover the containers completely, while Mississippi State says to cover food loosely when refrigerating so heat can escape.
Rutgers and Mississippi State agree on the storage window: leftovers should not be kept more than four days. The Rutgers fact sheet adds that leftovers should be heated to 165 degrees Fahrenheit throughout, with sauces, soups and gravies brought to a boil. Food Plus Words covered the three-to-four-day window and the rolling boil for soups and gravies in earlier reports.
The two-hour limit appears elsewhere in food-safety advice too. Utah State Extension has warned that cooked rice left out longer than two hours can carry toxins that reheating does not destroy.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Food Plus Words Newsletter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: USDAgov – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons
