This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
New York City is packed with hidden gems, and that includes the grocery scene too. Beyond the big-name supermarkets, locals have their own secret go-to spots packed with rare finds, unbeatable prices, and old-school charm.
These stores are woven into the fabric of their neighborhoods, offering flavors, history, and heart you just can’t get from the usual chains. These are the grocery stores New Yorkers quietly treasure and maybe wish would stay under the radar a little longer.
Kalustyan’s
WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?
Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!
Kalustyan’s in Manhattan is a spice lover’s dream, stocked with hundreds of global seasonings, oils, and specialty goods you won’t find anywhere else. Locals swear by its shelves for secret ingredients that turn everyday meals into masterpieces.
Essex Market
Lower East Side’s Essex Market feels like a neighborhood secret, offering fresh produce, specialty foods, and artisan finds under one roof. Shoppers love that it’s a throwback to the old New York marketplace vibe, friendly, bustling, and full of surprises. Independent vendors give it a small-town feel in the middle of the big city buzz.
Duals Natural
In the East Village, Duals Natural is where locals score organic produce, hard-to-find teas, and specialty health products. The cozy vibe and knowledgeable staff make it a favorite for anyone looking to shop consciously and find hidden wellness gems.
Sahadi’s
Sahadi’s in Brooklyn has been serving up Middle Eastern staples since 1948, and regulars still flock there for nuts, olives, spices, and sweets. Stepping inside feels like a trip overseas without ever leaving the borough. Their fresh hummus, bulk bins, and massive olive bar make it nearly impossible to leave empty-handed.
Westside Market
Westside Market is a New Yorker’s answer to fresh produce, artisanal cheeses, and prepared foods that taste like home cooking. With locations scattered around Manhattan, it’s a reliable secret for gourmet goods without the tourist crowds.
Paragon Sports Market
Tucked inside Paragon Sports near Union Square, this lesser-known food section stocks energy snacks, protein bars, and high-performance health foods. Locals love popping in for unique bites you won’t find in big grocery chains.
Related Post: 11 Iconic New York Delis That Locals Say Are Better Than Any Restaurant
Union Market
Union Market, with several Brooklyn locations, offers a curated shopping experience focused on organic produce, local meats, and sustainable seafood. It feels more like visiting a boutique than a grocery store, with quality that always shines through.
Related Post: 10 Restaurant Chains Born In Texas That Took Over The Nation
Hong Kong Supermarket
In Chinatown, Hong Kong Supermarket is the go-to spot for authentic Asian ingredients, live seafood, and specialty snacks. Locals rely on it for unbeatable variety and prices that make it easy to experiment with new dishes at home. From fresh dumpling wrappers to imported sweets, it’s a wonderland for adventurous home cooks.
Related Post: 14 Historic California Restaurants That Have Survived Every Trend
Mekelburg’s
Mekelburg’s in Brooklyn is part grocery, part bar, part sandwich heaven. Locals grab craft beers, fancy pantry staples, and some of the best deli sandwiches in the city, all in one stylish neighborhood shop. It’s the kind of place where a quick grocery trip turns into a casual night out without even planning it.
Related Post: 15 Iconic California Restaurants That Are Totally Worth The Hype
Ideal Food Basket
Tucked away across multiple boroughs, Ideal Food Basket delivers big value with fresh produce, pantry basics, and Latin American specialties. Shoppers appreciate the no-frills vibe and community feel that chain stores can’t replicate. Their selection of tropical fruits and freshly baked goods is a major highlight for families.
Related Post: 10 Grocery Stores In New York That Feel Like You’re In A Different Country
East Village Organic
A favorite for the health-conscious crowd, East Village Organic stocks local produce, gluten-free goodies, and all kinds of wellness products. It’s low-key, packed with treasures, and has the kind of neighborhood loyalty big brands dream of.
Related Post: 10 New York Restaurants That Went Viral For Totally Unexpected Reasons
Sign up now to receive our exclusive e-cookbook filled with top-rated recipes for FREE!
Foodtown of Williamsburg
While it may sound ordinary, Foodtown in Williamsburg is packed with surprises, from gourmet imports to freshly baked bread. Locals know it’s the perfect hidden-in-plain-sight spot for an affordable, satisfying grocery run. Their mix of classic staples and unique finds makes every trip there a new little adventure.
Related Post: 10 Texas Fast Food Joints That Outsiders Don’t Understand Until They Try Them
New Yorkers know their secret grocery stores are pure gold and they’re not always eager to share. From historic markets to boutique organic shops, these places prove that in a city full of everything, the best finds are still off the beaten path. Next time you’re in NYC, skip the tourist traps and shop where the real magic happens.
Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.
11 Hidden Grocery Stores In New York That Are Worth The Extra Subway Stop
New York City is packed with grocery stores, but not all of them are created equal. Beyond the big chains and crowded bodegas are hidden gems, unique markets that offer fresh ingredients, global flavors, and unbeatable prices.
Read it here: 11 Hidden Grocery Stores In New York That Are Worth The Extra Subway Stop
10 Grocery Stores In Florida That Retirees Swear By
Florida is a top destination for retirees, and when it comes to grocery shopping, they know exactly where to go for quality, value, and convenience. With years of experience and a focus on comfort, these savvy shoppers have their favorite stores down to a science.
Read it here: 10 Grocery Stores In Florida That Retirees Swear By
Is Walmart+ Still Worth It in 2025? The Truth After 3 Years
Is the new Walmart Plus worth the annual fee or is it just another failed version of Amazon Prime? I spent my own money trying this service out for 12 months and counting. I have a lot to say about the benefits and drawbacks in this Walmart+ honest review.
Read it here: Is Walmart+ Worth It? Honest Review 3 Years Later!
You’ll love these related posts:
- 11 Iconic Florida Seafood Shacks That Tourists Always Miss
- 10 Upstate New York Food Spots That Deserve National Attention
- 10 Fast Food Chains In Florida That Northerners Don’t Know About
- 12 Fast Casual Chains In Washington Locals Are Obsessed With
- 12 Fast Food Chains That Started In Florida And You Probably Didn’t Know It