Butchers and a Chef Name 8 Costco Meat Cuts Worth Buying Before Holiday Cooking, From Chuck Roll to Whole Brisket

This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.

Three food professionals who know meat counters well have named the 8 cuts they would put in a Costco cart. The list comes from Martha Stewart, which updated it on Nov. 14, just ahead of the holiday cooking season. Two butchers and a chef do the picking, and each cut comes with a named expert behind it.

Rosangela Teodoro, owner and butcher at Teodora’s Boucherie Gourmande in Massachusetts, picked chuck roll, whole beef tenderloin and whole brisket. Steve Sabicer, a former co-owner of Electric City Butcher in Southern California, backed brisket, short ribs and pork belly. Chef Clara Peck chose flank steak, boneless skinless chicken thighs and ground turkey.

The Beef Cuts the Butchers Pick

Teodoro calls chuck roll an overlooked value at Costco, according to the list as syndicated on Yahoo. The piece notes that its marbling and connective tissue suit slow, moist cooking, and that breaking it down yields Denver steaks, chuck eye, top blade and flat iron, with the trim going to pot roast, stew or ground beef.

She also names whole beef tenderloin, which the list frames as a cut for special occasions, since every ounce trimmed away is costly. It advises trimming it at home with a sharp knife, starting at the small end, and removing the silver skin. Trimmed, it gives filet mignon and grilling steaks.

Whole brisket is the one cut two experts agree on. Teodoro says a whole brisket is at its best smoked low and slow, and Sabicer also lists it among Costco’s best values. The list points out that a whole brisket has both a point and a flat, which gives two textures from one purchase.

Sabicer’s other beef pick is short ribs, which he calls a great cut for braising. He suggests beef bourguignon, birria or chili. Teodoro adds a caution that the large bone-in packs are hard to portion at home without a meat saw.

Pork Belly, Flank Steak and the Chef’s Everyday Picks

Sabicer’s third choice is pork belly. The list suggests it for homemade bacon, adobo, cassoulet or sausage.

Peck, founder of the culinary school Eat Cetera Philly, leads with flank steak, a quick-dinner cut to slice across the grain and pair with chimichurri or Worcestershire sauce.

Her other two picks are everyday proteins. Boneless, skinless chicken thighs are more affordable and flavorful than breasts, freeze well and resist drying out, and she uses them for braises, fried chicken and sheet-pan dinners. Ground turkey is her low-fat, high-protein all-rounder, which she turns into meatballs, chile verde and tacos.

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!

How the Experts Say to Shop and Store It

Sabicer says the real deals at Costco are in the vacuum-sealed products. The list suggests choosing vacuum-sealed packages over foam trays and checking the shipping boxes for origin details. Teodoro recommends the highest grade available, with USDA Prime favored for its intramuscular fat.

For big cuts, the list recommends labeling each package with the cut and the date before freezing. Portion the meat into roughly one-pound bags, press out the air, and thaw in the refrigerator the day before cooking. Double-wrapping in foil helps when breaking down large cuts.

Other Costco Meat Guides Back Several of the Picks

A June 2026 guide from The Takeout quotes Isaac Bernal Carbajo, executive chef of the representation of Spain to the United Nations. He named prime brisket, short ribs, tenderloin and chuck roast among his five best Costco cuts, backing this list’s brisket, short ribs and tenderloin, with chuck roast a close cousin of the list’s chuck roll.

A Tasting Table guide to Costco cuts for smoking, published June 29, 2026, lists beef brisket first, with chuck roast and beef ribs also on the list. For a whole brisket it advises looking for good marbling or a fat cap, smoking at 225 degrees Fahrenheit for 12 to 16 hours depending on size, and stopping at an internal temperature of 205 degrees.

Another Tasting Table piece from June 20, 2026 describes Kirkland Signature whole brisket as a cut that suits smoking, braising or corned beef, with leftovers that freeze well. An earlier Tasting Table roundup also counted boneless chuck roast, pork belly and chicken thighs among Costco’s best-value buys, with slow cooking advised for the chuck and pork belly.

Anyone planning a bigger spread can browse Food Plus Words’ holiday dinner ideas or holiday recipe ideas for more menu inspiration.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Johnsparks75 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Smoked_Brisket_with_smoke_ring.jpg)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *