This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
A family eggnog recipe that starts with raw eggs is one Utah State University Extension says to change before the holidays. Carolyn Washburn, a USU Extension professor, lays out the fix in a column on the Extension’s website: cook the egg mixture to 160 degrees Fahrenheit, then chill the finished eggnog in the refrigerator for 4 to 24 hours before serving. The same column offers a shortcut with pasteurized egg product for cooks who would rather skip the stove.
Why raw eggs are the sticking point
Washburn writes that a traditional eggnog recipe calling for raw eggs should be altered, because raw eggs may carry salmonella, a bacterium that causes foodborne illness. The column names infants, young children, pregnant women, older adults and people with weakened immune systems among those at higher risk.
A clean, uncracked shell does not settle the question. According to the column, refrigerated eggs in that condition can still be contaminated with salmonella.
The FDA’s holiday food safety page for expectant mothers makes the same point, saying bacteria might be inside some raw eggs, and its own eggnog recipe tells cooks the food thermometer should register 160 degrees F. Salmonella was also in the news this month, when the FDA added two new outbreaks ahead of Thanksgiving.
The double boiler, the spoon and the thermometer
Washburn’s cooked method calls for a 4-quart double boiler. The raw eggs go in with the milk and sugar, and the mixture is cooked and stirred over medium heat for approximately 10 to 15 minutes, until it coats a metal spoon and the temperature reaches 160 F.
Her full recipe uses 5 cups of skim milk, three-quarters of a cup of sugar and 4 eggs for that first step. Once the mixture reaches temperature, it comes off the heat.
Iowa State University Extension’s Answer Line gives the same doneness cues, according to its eggnog posts: the mixture should firmly coat a metal spoon and hold a clean line when a finger is drawn through it. Carla Due, a University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture extension agent in Miller County, says cooking a raw-egg base to 160 degrees while stirring constantly will destroy salmonella, if present.
Four to 24 hours in the refrigerator
The cooked base is not ready to drink. In Washburn’s recipe, a 12-ounce can of evaporated skim milk, 2 teaspoons of vanilla and an optional quarter teaspoon of rum extract are stirred in, and the bowl is covered and chilled for 4 to 24 hours.
Serving comes last. A pint of softened low-fat frozen vanilla yogurt goes into a punch bowl, the chilled eggnog is whisked in gradually until smooth, and nutmeg goes on top.
Iowa State’s Answer Line posts add a step for getting the pot cold faster: set the cooked mixture in ice water to stop the cooking, then refrigerate it.
One cup of pasteurized egg product in place of 4 eggs
Washburn’s first suggestion is to skip raw eggs entirely. The column says to use an equivalent amount of pasteurized egg product, frozen or refrigerated, that has never been opened, and to put any leftovers only into cooked foods because of the risk of contamination after opening.
In the recipe, 1 cup of pasteurized refrigerated egg product, or 1 cup of pasteurized frozen product thawed in the refrigerator, replaces the 4 eggs. Cooks using it follow the chilling and serving steps and leave out the 160-degree cooking step, the column says.
The column adds two related notes. A recipe that folds in beaten egg whites needs pasteurized eggs, since it has not been proven that raw whites are free of salmonella. Commercially prepared eggnog contains pasteurized eggs and does not need cooking.
Not every extension source stops there. Iowa State’s posts say the FDA and USDA still recommend starting with a cooked egg base even when the eggs are pasteurized, which is more cautious than the shortcut in Washburn’s recipe.
Why a splash of rum does not count as cooking
Washburn’s column says alcohol will inhibit bacterial growth but cannot be relied upon to kill bacteria, and that once it is diluted it no longer kills bacteria effectively. Pasteurized eggs are still needed, and simmering eggnog to cook it would remove the alcohol.
Due makes the same point, saying that adding rum, whiskey or other liquor does not make a raw-egg eggnog safe. An NC State News piece featuring food safety researcher Ben Chapman says ethanol kills some pathogens but is not a reliable safety measure, citing a 2010 study in which ethanol alone cut salmonella by 1.5 log, or 90 to 99 percent, over 24 hours, with no reduction in the first 60 minutes.
Food Plus Words’ own spiked eggnog recipe uses raw egg yolks and notes that cooks concerned about foodborne illness can use pasteurized eggs or heat the milk mixture with the yolks to 160 degrees. For more ways to spike a batch, there is a roundup of 19 eggnog cocktails.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Food Plus Words Newsletter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Wheeler Cowperthwaite – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons
