A Great-Grandmother Has Baked the Same Thanksgiving Rolls Since 1970 and Still Uses the Shortening That Was Cheaper Than Butter Back Then

This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.

Bette Sullivan has made the same dinner rolls for Thanksgiving for 56 years, and the dough still gets shortening, just as it did in 1970, when shortening cost less than butter or margarine. Allrecipes told her story in a piece published Nov. 8, 2026, and AOL carried it under a headline that calls her a great-grandmother. The recipe comes from the Better Homes and Gardens New Cook Book.

A Mother of Six Who Cooked From Scratch

Sullivan raised six boys and cooked mostly from scratch, according to the Allrecipes profile by Patricia Kaowthumrong. She grew vegetables and preserved food to stretch the family’s grocery budget.

She now lives in the Seattle-Tacoma area with her son, her daughter-in-law, her grandson and three dogs, the same piece reports.

In a kitchen run that way, the price of an ingredient mattered. That is where the shortening comes in.

Shortening in the Dough, Butter Saved for the Pan

When Sullivan was making these rolls in 1970, Allrecipes reports, shortening was cheaper than butter or margarine, so shortening went into the dough. Fifty-six years later, it still does.

The butter goes elsewhere. She sprays a muffin tin with cooking spray, then adds about 2 teaspoons of butter to each cup. The shaped balls of dough are rolled in melted butter, and each cup holds three of them.

Fat is not required in a yeast bread, according to Iowa State University Extension’s Answerline. The post says it adds flavor and tenderness and helps bread stay fresh longer. Its basic white bread recipe lists 3 tablespoons of shortening or butter, so either one works in that formula.

Everybody Pitched In on Thanksgiving

As her boys got older, Thanksgiving dinner became a family project in which everyone was expected to help, Allrecipes reports. One son made the mashed potatoes and another peeled the carrots. The youngest took charge of the green bean casserole.

Her son Michael was in charge of the dinner rolls. The article names no other sons.

Food Plus Words has plenty more for the rest of that table, including 15 dressing recipes for Thanksgiving and 25 easy Thanksgiving recipes for last-minute gatherings.

What Goes Into the Rolls and How They Bake

The recipe was published in the Better Homes and Gardens New Cook Book. A Vanderbilt University library exhibit lists that book as a 1968 Meredith Press publication, two years before the 1970 date in her shortening story.

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!

The dough starts with all-purpose flour, active dry yeast, milk, sugar, shortening, salt and eggs. The version printed with the story calls for a cup of milk, a third of a cup each of sugar and shortening, and two eggs, with margarine or butter allowed in place of the shortening.

The milk, sugar, fat and salt are warmed first, then combined with the flour mixture and the eggs. After 6 to 8 minutes of kneading, the dough rises for about an hour. It is then punched down, divided in half, left to rest for 10 minutes and shaped, and it rises a second time until nearly doubled. The recipe makes 24 to 32 rolls.

Iowa State’s extension post lists flour, yeast, liquid, sugar, salt and fat as the core ingredients of bread and says eggs are optional and more common in rolls. It gives a first rise of about 45 to 60 minutes in a warm place, until the dough doubles.

Sullivan bakes the rolls on the bottom rack of the oven at 375°F for 12 to 15 minutes, until the bottoms are crisp and buttery. In the Allrecipes piece, she describes the result this way: “The rolls are not only buttery, they’re somewhat crisp, as if they were fried.”

Not Just for Thanksgiving, and Barely Changed

Sullivan makes the rolls three or four times a year and thinks they go well with beef stew. Over the years she has tried whole-wheat flour and a different amount of sugar, and has experimented with the fat. She says she has played around with the recipe, but the original remains her base.

Exact measurements and directions are in the full recipe on Allrecipes.

For readers who want another seasonal bread on the table, Food Plus Words has a pumpkin dinner rolls recipe and a list of 25 fall bread recipes.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: jeffreyw – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fresh_hot_dinner_rolls_(8214213532).jpg)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *