This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
Some ice cream toppings sound fun until you realize they are a bit too wild for comfort. People keep trying to outdo each other by piling on strange things, hoping to stand out.
From spicy sauces to crunchy bugs, these toppings push boundaries. They leave many people wondering if the sweet treat underneath even stands a chance. Ice cream might be the star, but these extras steal the show.
Hot Cheetos
WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?
Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!
Some people sprinkle Hot Cheetos over vanilla or chocolate ice cream for a spicy crunch. Fans love the mix of cold and heat, but others say it overwhelms the creamy flavors and leaves a strange aftertaste. Not everyone wants their dessert to burn.
Wasabi Peas
These crunchy green peas bring heat and a sharp kick to ice cream. Adventurous eaters claim that wasabi peas create an exciting contrast with sweet flavors. Still, many find the pungent spice a bit much for dessert. One bite leaves your sinuses tingling, not everyone’s idea of fun.
Soy Sauce
A few daring ice cream shops drizzle soy sauce on vanilla scoops for an umami twist. While salty sweet blends can be tasty, soy sauce can easily overpower delicate flavors. Some say it makes ice cream taste like dinner instead of dessert, leaving many confused.
Olive Oil and Sea Salt
This topping sounds classy but surprises some people with its savory taste. The olive oil’s richness can work well on creamy gelato, but not everyone enjoys the slick texture. The salt adds a nice touch, though some diners feel they are eating a salad topping.
Garlic Cloves
Garlic ice cream, especially with minced raw garlic as a topping, shows up at garlic festivals and novelty shops. Fans claim it is savory and sweet, but most people call it vile and breath ruining. Many feel raw garlic on ice cream deserves to be banned completely.
Related Post: 11 Texas Markets That Outsell National Giants Without You Noticing
Fish Flakes
Some ice cream shops in Japan and adventurous spots in the U.S. have served soft serve sprinkled with dried bonito flakes. The smoky, fishy flavor curls and waves on the cold surface. Many people gag at fish on ice cream, insisting seafood belongs nowhere near dessert.
Related Post: 10 Hidden Farmers Market Gems That Could Be The Best Kept Secrets In Your City
Pickle Slices
Pickles on ice cream have a devoted following, especially among people who like sweet and sour. The crunch can be fun, but some folks think the tangy vinegar ruins the dessert. Many say pickles belong on burgers, not in a sundae cup.
Related Post: 12 Regional Easter Foods You’ll Only Find In These American States
Sriracha Sauce
This spicy sauce has found its way onto ice cream. Some love the heat and sweetness together, but others say Sriracha makes ice cream too fiery and intense. One spoonful and your mouth feels like a chili contest, which is not what everyone wants.
Related Post: 11 Easter Grocery Deals Across That Shoppers Are Racing To Grab
Peppercorns
Whole peppercorns on ice cream bring a spicy punch. They crack under your teeth and release heat. Some gourmet chefs swear by the combo, but many people feel like they are chewing pepper straight from the grinder instead of enjoying a sweet dessert moment.
Related Post: 12 Easter Brunch Spots Across America That Locals Swear Are Better Than Grandma’s
Chili Crisp
Chili crisp drizzled on ice cream surprises people with fiery heat, garlicky crunch, and sizzling oil. Fans love the spicy, savory layer against sweet scoops. Others say it completely ruins dessert. Many insist chili oil belongs on noodles, not melting into ice cream.
Related Post: 10 American Restaurants That Have Been Featured On Popular TV Shows You Need To Visit Now
Sign up now to receive our exclusive e-cookbook filled with top-rated recipes for FREE!
Bacon Bits
Salty bacon bits on ice cream became trendy for a while. Some people enjoy the savory sweet combo, but others say it ruins the dessert’s smooth vibe. Cold ice cream and chewy meat are not a match that everyone wants, even if it sounds fancy in theory.
Related Post: 13 Grocery Stores Near National Parks That Locals Say Are Worth The Detour
Balsamic Vinegar
Balsamic vinegar drizzled over ice cream surprises many people. Fans love how the tangy, sweet vinegar pairs with creamy vanilla or strawberry scoops. Others feel it tastes too savory and belongs on salads, not dessert. It is one topping that divides ice cream lovers quickly.
Related Post: 13 California Grocery Stores That Locals Say Beat Trader Joe’s Every Time
Wild toppings make ice cream adventurous, but not everyone wants surprises in every spoonful. Sometimes, plain sprinkles are perfect. Still, trying something weird might give you a story to tell next time you visit your favorite ice cream shop.
Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.
10 Ice Cream Trends People Over 40 Just Don’t Get
Ice cream was once the picture of simplicity, you had vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. If you felt daring, maybe mint chip. It was about the joy of something cold and creamy on a warm day, with no complicated backstory or Instagram filter involved.
Today, though, ice cream has been completely reimagined. It is infused, deconstructed, dusted, and renamed, often in ways that leave anyone over forty wondering if dessert needed a rebrand.
Read it here: 10 Ice Cream Trends People Over 40 Just Don’t Get
How to Save $100+ Every Month at the Grocery Store
From planning your meals to avoiding sneaky upcharges in the snack aisle, here’s a realistic guide to trimming your food budget without adding stress to your week.
Read it here: Things Moms Waste Money On (and Don’t Even Know It)
Is Walmart+ Still Worth It in 2025? The Truth After 3 Years
Is the new Walmart Plus worth the annual fee or is it just another failed version of Amazon Prime? I spent my own money trying this service out for 12 months and counting. I have a lot to say about the benefits and drawbacks in this Walmart+ honest review.
Read it here: Is Walmart+ Worth It? Honest Review 3 Years Later!
You’ll love these related posts:
- 11 New York Grocery Stores Where You’re Probably Overpaying Right Now
- 10 Restaurants In Ohio That Are Worth The Drive From Any Major City
- 11 Ohio Restaurants That Still Serve Food Like It’s The 1950s
- 12 Hidden Grocery Gems In New York That Even Born-And-Raised Locals Miss
- 11 Health-Focused Grocery Stores in Colorado That Actually Taste Good