This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
When most people think of dining in Florida, they picture beachfront cafes, high-end seafood spots, or theme park dining.
But ask the locals, and they’ll steer you toward the hidden gems, those under-the-radar restaurants that deliver flavor, charm, and authenticity without all the hype. From strip mall surprises to retro diners, here are 11 underrated Florida restaurants that locals quietly love and kind of hope tourists don’t find.
La Teresita
WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?
Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!
Tampa locals know that when you’re craving authentic Cuban food, La Teresita is the place to go. It’s no-frills, affordable, and packed with flavor, especially the roast pork, plantains, and café con leche served just the way abuela used to make it.
El Siboney
In the heart of Key West, El Siboney stands out as a favorite among locals who prefer home-style Cuban over touristy fare. The portions are hearty, the service is fast, and the flavors are as vibrant as the island itself.
Yellow Dog Eats
Gotha might be a small Florida town, but it’s home to one of the most delightfully quirky BBQ spots around. Yellow Dog Eats serves creative sandwiches and pulled pork in a converted historic house, with fun dog-themed décor to match.
Blue Heaven
Tucked away in a quieter part of Key West, Blue Heaven is a local favorite thanks to its laid-back vibe, roosters wandering the yard, and legendary brunch. Their lobster benedict and mile-high key lime pie keep regulars coming back.
The Floridian
In St. Augustine, The Floridian is a cozy eatery offering Southern comfort food with a modern twist. Think pimento cheese grits, seasonal veggies, and dishes that highlight local farms and flavors.
TacoLu
Jacksonville Beach locals love TacoLu for its bold tacos, tequila selection, and funky atmosphere. While it’s no longer a total secret, it still feels like a neighborhood hangout with unbeatable late-night bites.
Related Post: 10 Restaurant Chains Born In Texas That Took Over The Nation
Columbia Restaurant
While most tourists head to the original Columbia Restaurant in Tampa’s Ybor City, those in Sarasota know that the St. Armands Circle location serves the same iconic Spanish Cuban fare, without the crowds. Locals love the 1905 Salad and sangria made tableside.
Related Post: 10 New York Restaurants That Went Viral For Totally Unexpected Reasons
Moonlite Diner
In Hollywood, Florida, Moonlite Diner is a beloved spot for breakfast-all-day, classic burgers, and milkshakes served with a retro vibe. Locals appreciate the nostalgia and comfort food, especially after a night out.
Related Post: 10 Grocery Stores In New York That Feel Like You’re In A Different Country
The Whale
Just off Siesta Key in Sarasota, The Whale is a chill seafood joint that flies under the radar. Regulars come for the fish tacos, cold drinks, and casual post-beach atmosphere that never tries too hard.
Related Post: 15 Iconic California Restaurants That Are Totally Worth The Hype
Little Moir’s Food Shack
Jupiter might be known for its luxury, but Little Moir’s Food Shack proves that unassuming spots can steal the culinary spotlight. Located in a strip mall, this seafood gem offers bold, fresh dishes that surprise first-timers and keep locals loyal.
Related Post: 14 Historic California Restaurants That Have Survived Every Trend
Red Mesa Cantina
St. Petersburg’s Red Mesa Cantina mixes Latin fusion with rooftop vibes and flavorful cocktails. While visitors might overlook it in favor of flashier venues, locals know it’s one of the best places in town for lively atmosphere and consistent quality.
Related Post: 10 Underrated Texas Restaurants That Locals Are Keeping Secret On Purpose
Sign up now to receive our exclusive e-cookbook filled with top-rated recipes for FREE!
Florida’s restaurant scene is full of surprises, and these underrated spots prove that the best meals often come from places without the fanfare. Whether you’re road-tripping through the state or a local looking to branch out, keep these hidden gems on your radar and thank us later.
Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.
25 Baking Ideas That’ll Make Your Kitchen Smell Like Heaven
These baking ideas will make your entire house smell like a bakery. From sweet baked desserts to a few savory baked breads, these are perfect for when you’re in the mood to bake up something tasty.
Read it here: 25 Baking Ideas That’ll Make Your Kitchen Smell Like Heaven
25 Brunch Food Ideas That Will Elevate Your Weekend Feasts
Elevate your weekend feasts or special celebrations with these brunch food ideas. There’s a little something here for everyone with a collection of both sweet and savory.
Read it here: 25 Brunch Food Ideas That Will Elevate Your Weekend Feasts
Is Walmart+ Still Worth It in 2025? The Truth After 3 Years
Is the new Walmart Plus worth the annual fee or is it just another failed version of Amazon Prime? I spent my own money trying this service out for 12 months and counting. I have a lot to say about the benefits and drawbacks in this Walmart+ honest review.
Read it here: Is Walmart+ Worth It? Honest Review 3 Years Later!
You’ll love these related posts:
- 25 Ground Beef Dinner Ideas To Spice Up Your Dinner Routine
- 25 Brunch Ideas So Good, You’ll Want Them Every Weekend
- 25 Easy Breakfast Ideas for a Crowd That’ll Keep Everyone Full and Happy
- 25 Meal Ideas for Dinner To Upgrade Your Weeknights
- 25 Baby Shower Food Ideas That Make Celebrating Even Sweeter