This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
Savory meat jellies, a soda warmed on the stove and a frozen turkey salad all had their turn on American holiday tables. Taste of Home trends writer Lindsay Parrill gathered nine of those retired dishes from earlier generations’ holiday tables in a list published Nov. 13, 2026, which Yahoo Lifestyle also carried the same day. Three of them set the tone: savory aspics that stayed respectable into the 1950s, hot Dr Pepper that Dr Pepper itself introduced in the 1960s, and a frozen jellied turkey vegetable salad from the 1970s.
Meat Set in a Mold and Served With Pride
Savory aspics and meat jellies come first on Parrill’s list. They were suspensions of meat, vegetables, seafood and hard-boiled eggs, set in elaborate molds and sliced into portions, and they remained respectable holiday fare into the 1950s. Parrill admires the work involved but would not want to eat one.
Fox News reported in November 2025 that savory aspics and Jell-O salads were mid-century status symbols tied to refrigeration and convenience, according to chef Jessica Randhawa of The Forked Spoon.
The Jell-O salads that followed were just as popular in the mid-20th century. Parrill names a cranberry gelatin salad and a lime version with pineapple, and notes that some versions added carrots, celery, mayonnaise or canned tuna. The cranberry one would get a spot on a modern table, Parrill says. The tuna one would not. Anyone curious about the gentler end of that tradition can try the site’s strawberry Jello salad.
Mincemeat Pie and Waldorf Salad, Two Classics From the 1890s
Mincemeat pie once ranked alongside pumpkin and apple, especially in the 1890s, according to Taste of Home. The filling of dried fruit, spices and citrus came from English cooking, and early versions contained beef or mutton and suet before the meat was gradually dropped. Mental Floss traces mince pies to the 11th century and says the meatless version became the standard after Eliza Acton published both styles in the 1840s. Parrill would welcome a modest comeback.
Waldorf salad has a clearer birthday. Taste of Home says it was created at New York’s Waldorf Hotel in the 1890s as apples, celery and mayonnaise, with walnuts added later, and that by the 1960s it was common beside roast turkey. Oscar Tschirky, the hotel’s maitre d’hotel, is widely credited with the recipe, first made in 1896 for a charity ball. Parrill calls it one of the easiest dishes on the list to revive.
Hot Dr Pepper, Pushed by the Soda Company Itself
Taste of Home says Dr Pepper introduced the drink in the 1960s as a warm winter beverage. The method was simple: heat the soda, pour it into a mug and float a thin slice of lemon on top. Parrill is undecided but open to trying it.
Tasting Table’s Annie Johnston wrote in January 2024 that Dr Pepper was advertised as a hot drink in the 1960s, with marketing teams promoting it to offset the winter drop in cold-drink sales, and that the soda is heated to about 180 degrees Fahrenheit. The Dr Pepper Museum traces the idea further back to company president Wesby R. Parker, who was at a bottling plant during a blizzard when a route salesman joked that the company needed a hot drink to sell in winter. The museum says it remained a popular holiday drink into the 1970s.
Vegetable Loaf, Cranberry Candles and a Frozen Turkey Salad
The holiday vegetable loaf appeared in the 1950s, with vegetables bound by eggs, breadcrumbs or gelatin and served either baked or cold and unmolded. Parrill questions the idea of making vegetables resemble meatloaf.
Cranberry mayonnaise candles were molded from cranberry sauce and mayonnaise into a candle shape with a decorative wick or flame. Food companies promoted them, though the article gives no era, and Parrill questions the concept as well.
The frozen jellied turkey vegetable salad is the 1970s entry. It combined turkey, vegetables and a gelatin mixture into a cold, molded, sliceable salad, a way to put leftover turkey to use. Parrill finds it unnecessary. Today, leftover turkey has a more familiar route, covered in the site’s rundown of USDA’s Thanksgiving leftover guidance.
Creamed Pearl Onions and the Case for a Comeback
The list ends with a dish that Parrill would bring back. Creamed pearl onions were familiar on Thanksgiving tables in the 1920s, with tender onions in a buttery cream sauce served alongside turkey, mashed potatoes and stuffing. Parrill suggests frozen pearl onions to simplify the preparation and thinks the dish deserves a return.
Plenty of holiday dishes never left at all, like the dinner rolls a great-grandmother has baked since 1970, and food memories still run strong, as the site’s look at a Campbell’s green bean casserole survey showed.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Food Plus Words Newsletter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Shadle – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons
