This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
Yogurt and cheese are often held up as muscle-friendly foods for older adults, but a new Irish analysis could not tie either one to stronger grip or steadier aging. A team led by Dominic Farsi of the Teagasc Food Research Centre studied 6,790 adults aged 50 and older and found no consistent link between fermented dairy and grip strength, mobility, self-care limits or frailty once other factors were accounted for. The paper appeared in the European Journal of Nutrition in November 2026, and News-Medical reported on it on Nov. 11.
Two Irish Groups and Four Ways of Testing How Well They Age
The researchers pooled data from two long-running studies of older adults. The Northern Ireland Cohort for the Longitudinal Study of Ageing, known as NICOLA, contributed 2,791 people with an average age of 64. The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing, or TILDA, added 3,999 people with an average age of 66, according to the full paper.
The design was cross-sectional, meaning diet and physical function were measured at one point in time. Each group filled out its own food frequency questionnaire about the previous year. News-Medical reported that NICOLA recorded daily grams of cheese, yogurt and other fermented dairy, while TILDA recorded only yogurt and cheese as approximate frequency.
Four outcomes were checked. Grip strength was measured with a handheld device, with low strength defined as under 27 kilograms for men and under 16 kilograms for women. Mobility was timed with the Timed Up-and-Go test, in which a person stands from an armchair, walks three meters, turns and sits back down. Self-care was based on self-reported trouble with dressing, bathing, eating, using the toilet and getting out of bed. Frailty came from an index of 30 health deficits.
Why the Raw Patterns Faded After Adjustment
In NICOLA, fermented dairy intake was not associated with physical function once confounders were adjusted for, the study abstract says. Crude comparisons had shown some links, but they weakened after adjustment, and there was no dose-response pattern, meaning more yogurt or cheese did not line up with steadily better results.
The adjustments mattered because heavier dairy eaters differed from lighter ones in other ways. News-Medical reported that the top consumers in NICOLA were more often women, better educated and more physically active. The paper also notes they took in more total energy and protein. Higher consumers looked somewhat less frail on paper, but that did not hold up after full adjustment.
The authors wrote that raw patterns may partly reflect broader differences in health habits, diet quality and income rather than an effect of fermented dairy itself.
The One TILDA Result That Pointed the Other Way
One finding stood out in the TILDA group. The highest third of fermented dairy eaters had higher odds of low grip strength than the lowest third, with an odds ratio of 2.71, according to PubMed. The authors said it was driven by yogurt and faded after covariate adjustment.
They also called it a likely spurious finding, because it did not appear when grip strength was measured as a continuous number or in the other functional tests. Cheese showed no consistent associations in TILDA.
The authors offered one possible explanation, reverse causation. Older adults whose strength is already slipping may lean on soft, easy foods such as yogurt or cottage cheese, which could make yogurt eaters look weaker in a one-time snapshot.
What the Study Cannot Say About Yogurt, Cheese and Aging Muscles
The result is a lack of evidence, not proof that fermented dairy does nothing. Because diet and function were measured together, cause and effect cannot be established. Muscle mass and gut microbiome makeup were not measured, and food questionnaires can contain reporting errors. The authors described the work as primarily hypothesis-generating.
They called for longitudinal studies and randomized controlled trials, and for research that accounts for physical activity, especially resistance exercise, since muscles respond strongly to mechanical loading.
Other dairy and protein findings on the site cover different ground, including a University of Toronto trial of full-fat dairy, a report on how many species kefir holds compared with yogurt, and a dietitian’s numbers on the protein in lentils.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Food Plus Words Newsletter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Rawpixel – CC0 1.0
