This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
One A Day Kids Multi Gummies measured 531% of the labeled vitamin C when Consumer Reports had the product tested, according to a report published Nov. 10. The same gummy came in at 504% of its labeled vitamin B9, also known as folate. The nonprofit tested 21 children’s vitamins in all, and every one had at least one nutrient above or below the amount on its label.
The results are about label accuracy. Consumer Reports says every vitamin in the test is safe to take or keep taking.
How One A Day Kids Multi Gummies Compared With Its Label
Consumer Reports bought one to three lots of each product and sent them to an outside accredited laboratory. The lab measured 12 vitamins and minerals in each, and the average result was compared with the Supplement Facts label and with a tolerance range from the U.S. Pharmacopeia, known as USP.
The One A Day gummy is labeled for ages 4 to 13, at two gummies a serving. Its vitamin C reading was about 5.3 times the labeled amount. Consumer Reports says USP allows vitamin C in gummies to run as high as 250% of the label, so the reading was more than double that ceiling, as a health policy newsletter on Substack also noted.
Vitamin B9 in the same product measured 504% of the label, against a USP cap of 245%. WSOC-TV reported the same two figures in a Nov. 14 story.
Why Bayer Says Some Nutrients Run Above the Label
A Bayer spokesperson told Consumer Reports the company “stands behind the quality and safety” of its One A Day and Flintstones products. Bayer said it intentionally formulates certain nutrients above the labeled amount so they stay at appropriate levels through the product’s shelf life, consistent with industry practice.
Consumer Reports confirms that practice exists. USP tolerance ranges allow for some overages in gummies, and several companies told the nonprofit they add extra nutrients for that reason. Bayer also said its own testing shows the nutrients stay within the established safe range of what the label states.
Consumer Reports adds two limits to its findings. USP standards are voluntary unless a product is USP-certified, and the group says it is not a regulatory body, so no legal judgments can be made from its results. The numbers are a snapshot, and manufacturers can change formulas at any time.
What the Upper Intake Level Means for Children and Vitamin C
The 531% figure compares the lab result with the label. It is not a comparison with a safety limit, which is a separate measure in milligrams. The National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplements lists daily upper limits for vitamin C of 400 mg for ages 1 to 3, 650 mg for ages 4 to 8, 1,200 mg for ages 9 to 13 and 1,800 mg for teens 14 to 18. Those limits count vitamin C from all sources, including food, drinks and supplements.
The NIH says taking too much vitamin C can cause diarrhea, nausea and stomach cramps. Consumer Reports describes the upper intake level as the total daily intake of a supplemented nutrient that is unlikely to cause adverse health effects, and calls these conservative levels.
Two of the 21 products had at least one nutrient above the upper limit for the intended age group, and the nutrients named were niacin, folate and zinc. Vitamin C was not among them. The newsletter analysis names Equate’s chewable and NaturesPlus Animal Parade as those two products, and Consumer Reports did not name One A Day among them.
Consumer Reports says high amounts of water-soluble vitamins such as vitamin C and the B vitamins are less concerning than fat-soluble vitamins or zinc, because they are flushed from the body. Excess intake can still cause stomach upset or cramping, the report says.
What Else the 21-Product Test Found
Of 206 nutrients analyzed across the 21 products, 61 fell outside the thresholds Consumer Reports used, or 29%. The test turned up cases as much as 500% above the labeled amount, as News4JAX reported on Nov. 11.
Gummies did better than other formats. Every chewable, tablet, capsule and powder in the test had at least one nutrient below the acceptable range, while gummies were more likely to land within or above it. Nature Made Kids First Multi With Omega-3 and Olly Kids Multi & Probiotic, both third-party certified, each had just one nutrient out of range.
Trace amounts of lead turned up in every product, and low levels of arsenic and cadmium appeared in 16 of the 21. Mercury showed up in 8. None exceeded the level Consumer Reports’ experts set for concern. Bayer’s Flintstones Complete Chewable Tablets were also among the 21 products tested.
What Pediatric Experts Say About Kids’ Vitamins
The American Academy of Pediatrics says most children do not need a daily vitamin, WRAL reported. A supplement can help in some cases, such as a very limited diet, multiple food allergies, a diagnosed deficiency or a medical condition that raises the risk of one.
Consumer Reports cites the 2024 National Poison Data System report, which found supplement overdose was the fifth most common cause of poisoning in children 5 and under. Whitney Casares, a pediatrician and American Academy of Pediatrics spokesperson, said it is easy for children to eat vitamins like candy when they are made to taste good.
Experts advise looking for a third-party certification seal and asking a pediatrician before starting a supplement, according to WCVB. Experts quoted by Consumer Reports favor a food-first approach, such as adding fruit and vegetables at snack time. Kid-friendly ideas include healthy lunchbox ideas and school snacks built around real food.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Food Plus Words Newsletter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
