This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
Plain, unsweetened cranberry juice swished around the mouth slowed the regrowth of dental plaque bacteria and cut the acid they produce, while a sweetened cranberry cocktail and plain water did not. The result comes from a Scientific Reports paper by researchers at the University of Illinois Chicago College of Dentistry, led by Christine D. Wu, a professor of pediatric dentistry. It covered 22 people, 14 children and 8 adults, and its own authors call it small and short.
Pure Juice Held Back Plaque Regrowth and Acid
The paper reports that unsweetened 100% cranberry juice reduced average plaque regrowth by 43.93 percent in adults and 33.04 percent in children. After 4 hours, the regrowth of adult plaque came in at 56.1 percent of the pre-drink level, and children’s plaque at 66.96 percent.
Acid production dropped as well. Plaque exposed to the pure juice reached a pH of 5.542 after 2 hours in adults and 5.569 in children, a smaller fall than in unexposed plaque, which landed between about 5.0 and 5.2 in the paper’s tables. A lower pH means more acid, and acid is what erodes enamel.
The authors also found that pure juice did not significantly reduce bacterial viability, reported Medical Dialogues. The bacteria were slowed rather than wiped out.
How the Swish-and-Swallow Test Was Run
According to the UIC release distributed through Newswise, participants arrived with the plaque that had built up overnight. Researchers swabbed plaque from one side of the mouth for a baseline, and participants then rinsed and swished their assigned drink.
The paper gives the details. Recruits were medically healthy people seeking care at the UIC College of Dentistry: children aged 7 to 12 with healthy gums, and adult non-smokers aged 18 to 64 with at least 20 natural teeth. Participants avoided brushing for at least 24 hours and ate and drank nothing but water from 10 p.m. the night before. Each swished 10 milliliters of drink for 30 seconds, swallowed, and repeated the step twice more with a 30-second wait between rounds.
Thirty minutes later, plaque was swabbed from the other side of the mouth. The adult and child studies were both randomized crossover trials, so each participant tried more than one drink, with a three-day break between visits and the order decided by a coin flip. The plaque samples were then grown in the lab for 2 and 4 hours, with sugar added, so acid and regrowth could be measured against each person’s own baseline sample.
The Sweetened Cocktail Fell Short
The comparison drink was Ocean Spray’s cranberry juice cocktail, made with 27% juice and 32 grams of added sugar per serving. In children, neither the cocktail nor water slowed plaque regrowth. In adults, the cocktail brought regrowth down to 75.2 percent at 4 hours, but the paper says the drop was not statistically significant.
The authors attribute the pure juice’s edge to its higher content of proanthocyanidins, plant compounds in cranberries. They also note that cranberry juice has far less sugar, 4 to 5 grams per 8 ounces, than orange or apple juice at 20 to 28 grams. The authors state that their own unpublished data indicate 100% apple juice does not slow acid production or plaque regrowth, and orange juice was not tested.
Sweetened mixes are a separate matter. The site’s non alcoholic Christmas punch, for example, pairs 1 cup of cranberry juice with orange juice, sparkling cider and Sprite, so it is nothing like the unsweetened juice used here.
What a 22-Person, 30-Minute Study Cannot Show
With so few participants and a single check 30 minutes after the drink, the study cannot show that drinking cranberry juice regularly prevents cavities or gives lasting benefits, according to ScienceDaily’s account of the UIC release. The authors say larger, longer studies are needed, and the paper reports no competing interests, with partial support from the university’s pediatric dentistry department.
Acidity is another question. The paper lists pure cranberry juice at a pH of about 2.31, but says evidence linking acidic drinks to tooth erosion is inconsistent and mostly from lab studies.
Wu suggests pure cranberry juice could be considered a functional beverage for oral health, according to News-Medical.Net. She is open to occasional use as a mouth rinse, ideally with a sugar substitute added, because the juice is so tart.
Readers who simply like the fruit can browse the site’s 25 cranberry recipes.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Food Plus Words Newsletter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Lisa Pinehill – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cranberry_juice_in_a_cup.jpg)
