Registered Dietitian and Mayo Clinic Researchers Weigh In as National Geographic Reports Kefir Has About 50 Species per Glass Compared With 5 or So in Most Yogurts

This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.

Jenna Smith, a registered dietitian and nutrition educator at the University of Illinois Extension, and Lioudmila Karnatovskaia, a critical care doctor at Mayo Clinic, are the main experts in a National Geographic report on why kefir may beat yogurt. The Nov. 5 report says kefir holds some 50 species of live bacteria and yeast per glass, compared with five or so in most yogurts. Smith calls kefir “a really wonderful drink from a health perspective,” while the research behind it is still early.

Where the 50-Species Figure Comes From

National Geographic links its “some 50 species per glass” line to a 2020 paper in the journal Microorganisms by University of Idaho researchers Abrar Sindi, Md. Bahadur Badsha and Gülhan Ünlü. That paper states that up to 50 different bacterial and yeast species have been identified in artisanal kefirs. The authors sequenced kefirs and grains from Britain, Ireland, Lithuania, South Korea, the Caucasus region and a fusion tea kefir to see which bacteria dominate.

The wording matters. The 50 covers both bacteria and yeast, and it is an upper limit reported for traditional grain-made kefir rather than a fixed count for every bottle. National Geographic gives the yogurt comparison as five or so in most yogurts.

A March 2026 review of kefir trials in the journal Healthcare explains the mix. Kefir grains hold a community of lactic acid bacteria, acetic acid bacteria and yeasts, and the species makeup varies with the grains’ origin, the fermentation conditions and the milk used. The same review notes that store-bought kefirs are often made from defined starter cultures meant to copy the grains, and may differ in microbial diversity.

Mayo Clinic’s Karnatovskaia on Why Diversity Matters

Karnatovskaia told National Geographic that a more diverse gut microbiome is generally a healthier one. Her interest in kefir comes from the intensive care unit, where she said microbiome diversity drops dramatically in the first six hours of critical illness and pathogenic strains expand. ICU patients also receive high doses of antibiotics that alter the gut.

She said the strains are the same in original and flavored kefir, but that sugar in flavored versions deserves attention.

What the 54-Patient Mayo Pilot Did and Did Not Show

The study Karnatovskaia mentions is a Mayo Clinic pilot published in BMC Medicine in February 2024. According to the paper, 54 critically ill adults were given kefir on an ascending schedule of 60 mL, then 120 mL 12 hours later, then 240 mL daily, and the authors concluded that providing kefir to critically ill people was safe and feasible. About 91% of prescribed doses were given, and 28 of the 54 patients received kefir through a nasogastric tube. No kefir-related bloodstream infection was reported.

The gut results were more mixed. Overall diversity did not rise, and the authors attributed a drop mainly to antibiotics. The Gut Microbiome Wellness Index, which Mayo’s Jaeyun Sung and other researchers created, improved significantly. Three kefir-associated Lactobacillus species became more common, but seven of the 12 kefir species the team tracked were not detected in any sample.

The pilot had no control group, and only 13 patients gave both an initial and a follow-up stool sample. Sung, a Mayo data scientist who worked on the study, said that making sure the gut recovers along with the rest of the body is important for a holistic recovery after an ICU stay. He and Karnatovskaia are seeking funding for a larger study with longer follow-up, National Geographic reported.

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

Enter your email below and we'll send the recipe straight to your inbox!

Two 2026 Reviews and Their Limits

The Healthcare review, by Sabina Fijan and colleagues at the University of Maribor in Slovenia, covered 28 human clinical trials. It found potential benefits for gut microbiota, metabolic markers, inflammation, immune function and digestive health, but also said the overall strength of evidence remains limited because kefir preparation, dosage and study populations varied so much.

A second 2026 review, in the journal MicrobiologyOpen, narrowed in on the gut. Researchers from nutrition and dietetics departments in Turkey and the United Arab Emirates found eight human intervention studies among 2,743 records and reported that kefir-specific bacteria turned up in participants’ stool samples, which suggests the microbes can colonize the gut. The authors described the overall changes in gut microbiota as modest and varied, and said direct evidence of function in humans remains limited.

The Healthcare review adds that kefir, as a fermented milk drink, does not meet the scientific definition of a probiotic. National Geographic summed up the findings as small but meaningful improvements and noted that kefir does not cure diseases, whatever some online claims say. Results in small trials on fatty liver disease, metabolic syndrome and inflammatory bowel disease were mixed.

Smith’s Buying and Drinking Advice

Smith said kefir is high in calcium, vitamin D and protein. She pointed to a University of Illinois test in which researchers sequenced the RNA of five commercial kefirs and found that some species listed on the labels were missing. Smith, who was not part of that research, said the likelier cause is that live cultures degrade quickly, which is why she recommends drinking kefir within a few days of opening.

There are no official consumption guidelines. Smith suggests kefir or other fermented foods about once a week, and daily when recovering from an illness. National Geographic reported that U.S. kefir sales grew 28% in 2025 to $253 million, according to the research firm Circana.

Home cooks who already keep a jar going can read how to freeze kefir grains when a batch needs a break, or try kefir in recipes such as the peach cobbler overnight oats in this list of healthy peach recipes.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *