This post may contain affiliate links which means I will get a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure for details.
At Sheetz this season, the stuffing does not come on the side. It is baked straight into the roll that holds the Holidaze Sub, a turkey sandwich that debuted last year and has now returned. The sub is on the menu at all of the chain’s more than 850 locations through the beginning of December.
What Goes Inside the Stuffing Roll
According to NACS, the new version of the sub starts with homemade stuffing baked into the roll. Inside it are turkey medallions, shredded cheese, gravy, crispy onions and cranberry-orange relish.
Sporked described the same build, down to the savory gravy and the crispy onions. Its writer, Vinz Karl, called the idea “bonkers but honestly, they have my attention,” and added that only time will tell how it turns out, so the piece stopped short of a taste verdict. Its headline sums up the pitch as all of the holiday in one sandwich.
Patch described the roll as the tweak Sheetz made to the sub for this season, and Sporked reported that the stuffing-in-the-roll technique took the culinary team nearly a year to perfect.
That roll is the heart of the change. Stuffing is usually a side dish on the plate, and here it becomes part of the bread that holds everything else.
Grandma’s Roll With a Sheetz Twist
Jacee Scoular, director of brand strategy and design at Sheetz, put the idea in family terms. Scioto Post quoted her as saying, “It’s the kind of roll Grandma would bake, with a little Sheetz imagination.”
Scioto Post also reported that Sheetz’s culinary team spent nearly a year developing the roll, and that the menu rolled out on Oct. 28. Patch reported the same launch day.
For the classic version baked in a dish, the site’s easy traditional stuffing recipe follows the old-fashioned route.
Flatzgiving and the Turkey Salad Share the Menu
The sub is not the only turkey item on the Holidaze menu. NACS reported that Flatzgiving is a new flatbread topped with turkey medallions, turkey gravy, provolone and mozzarella, crispy onions and cranberry-orange relish. Sporked suggested cutting the flatbread into small squares for a gathering.
The Turkey Bacon Cranberry Salad is also new. It is chopped romaine topped with turkey medallions, provolone and mozzarella, crispy onions and the same cranberry-orange relish, NACS said. Scioto Post also lists bacon among the toppings.
All three items lean on the same Thanksgiving pieces: turkey, gravy, onions and cranberry. Anyone who likes the gravy part of a holiday plate can find a home version in the site’s turkey gravy without drippings.
Where It Sits Among Holiday Turkey Sandwiches
Sheetz is not alone in the turkey-sandwich season. A Pirates and Princesses roundup of 2026 Thanksgiving sandwiches also listed Arby’s Deep Fried Turkey Gobbler, which returned Oct. 26 while supplies last, and the Wawa Gobbler, also back this fall. The roundup also noted the Firehouse Subs Thanksgiving Turkey Sub, back for fall, and Capriotti’s The Bobbie, which is on the menu all year.
The same roundup made the Sheetz Holidaze Sub its pick because the stuffing baked into the bread makes it stand out. It did not include a head-to-head taste test, and it did not list a price for the Sheetz sub.
A second roundup, from Burger Beast, also named the Holidaze Sub and Flatzgiving, and gave the end of the run as Dec. 2. NACS says only through the beginning of December.
How Long the Holidaze Menu Is Around
The Holidaze lineup is a seasonal run. It started Oct. 28 and stays at Sheetz locations through the beginning of December.
The timing holds across the coverage. Sporked’s piece ran on Oct. 30 and the NACS report followed on Nov. 6, and both put the end of the run at the beginning of December. Burger Beast named a specific last day, Dec. 2.
NACS reported that the Holidaze Sub is back after its debut last year, with the stuffing roll as the change. Another holiday roll story from the site, about a great-grandmother who has baked the same Thanksgiving rolls since 1970, shows how much a family’s own roll recipe can mean at the table.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Food Plus Words Newsletter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Aaron F. Stone – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons
